House · Oct 8, 2004 · Roll call 522

Sending back to committee (motion to recommit)

Failed

Official question: “On Motion to Recommit with Instructions” (RECORDED VOTE) · Embed in your story

Speaker of the House that day: J. Dennis Hastert

Aye193

D Cardoza CDD Dooley LC

D Millender-McDonald GN

D Frank MMD Meehan JT

D Bishop MOD Owens NV

D Kanjorski JHD Hoeffel MD

D Ford MSD Sandlin LD

D Doggett CE

D Edwards SR

D Reyes CSD Stenholm SJ

D Jackson Lee JT

D Turner CG

D Gonzalez MFD Frost CB

No223

R Shadegg JDR Hayworth JF

R Issa DCR Cunningham DH

R Shays NJR Johnson JM

R Biggert DHR Hastert TJ

R Johnson DM

R Manzullo RL

R LaHood JS

R Shimkus HHR Hyde PC

R Pence JHR Hostettler JM

R Fossella SKR Kelly JS

R Sweeney JM

R McHugh JW

R Walsh TR

R Reynolds JQR Quinn AH

R Turner MOR Oxley PG

R Weldon JGR Greenwood BS

R DeLay HBR Bonilla MB

R Cannon JAR Ann Davis FW

R Hastings GNR Nethercutt JD

Not Voting17

D Towns SBR Boehlert LS

Table of every position

Member	Party at vote	Seat	Position
Don Young	R	AK-AL	No
Jo Bonner	R	AL-1	No
Terry Everett	R	AL-2	No
Mike Rogers	R	AL-3	No
Robert Aderholt	R	AL-4	No
Bud Cramer	D	AL-5	Aye
Spencer Bachus	R	AL-6	No
Artur Davis	D	AL-7	Aye
Marion Berry	D	AR-1	Aye
Vic Snyder	D	AR-2	Aye
John Boozman	R	AR-3	No
Mike Ross	D	AR-4	Aye
Rick Renzi	R	AZ-1	No
Trent Franks	R	AZ-2	No
John Shadegg	R	AZ-3	No
Ed Pastor	D	AZ-4	Aye
J.D. Hayworth	R	AZ-5	No
Jeff Flake	R	AZ-6	No
Raúl Grijalva	D	AZ-7	Aye
Jim Kolbe	R	AZ-8	No
Mike Thompson	D	CA-1	Aye
Ellen Tauscher	D	CA-10	Aye
Richard Pombo	R	CA-11	No
Tom Lantos	D	CA-12	Aye
Pete Stark	D	CA-13	Aye
Anna Eshoo	D	CA-14	Aye
Mike Honda	D	CA-15	Aye
Zoe Lofgren	D	CA-16	Aye
Sam Farr	D	CA-17	Aye
Dennis Cardoza	D	CA-18	Aye
George Radanovich	R	CA-19	No
Wally Herger	R	CA-2	No
Cal Dooley	D	CA-20	Aye
Devin Nunes	R	CA-21	No
Bill Thomas	R	CA-22	No
Lois Capps	D	CA-23	Aye
Elton Gallegly	R	CA-24	No
Buck McKeon	R	CA-25	No
David Dreier	R	CA-26	No
Brad Sherman	D	CA-27	Aye
Howard Berman	D	CA-28	Aye
Adam Schiff	D	CA-29	Aye
Doug Ose	R	CA-3	No
Henry Waxman	D	CA-30	Aye
Xavier Becerra	D	CA-31	Aye
Hilda Solis	D	CA-32	Aye
Diane Watson	D	CA-33	Aye
Lucille Roybal-Allard	D	CA-34	Aye
Maxine Waters	D	CA-35	Aye
Jane Harman	D	CA-36	Aye
Juanita Millender-McDonald	D	CA-37	Aye
Grace Napolitano	D	CA-38	Aye
Linda Sánchez	D	CA-39	Aye
John Doolittle	R	CA-4	No
Ed Royce	R	CA-40	No
Jerry Lewis	R	CA-41	No
Gary Miller	R	CA-42	No
Joe Baca	D	CA-43	Aye
Ken Calvert	R	CA-44	No
Mary Bono Mack	R	CA-45	No
Dana Rohrabacher	R	CA-46	No
Loretta Sanchez	D	CA-47	Aye
C. Cox	R	CA-48	No
Darrell Issa	R	CA-49	No
Robert Matsui	D	CA-5	Not Voting
Duke Cunningham	R	CA-50	No
Bob Filner	D	CA-51	Not Voting
Duncan Hunter	R	CA-52	No
Susan Davis	D	CA-53	Aye
Lynn Woolsey	D	CA-6	Aye
George Miller	D	CA-7	Aye
Nancy Pelosi	D	CA-8	Aye
Barbara Lee	D	CA-9	Aye
Diana DeGette	D	CO-1	Aye
Mark Udall	D	CO-2	Aye
Scott McInnis	R	CO-3	No
Marilyn Musgrave	R	CO-4	No
Joel Hefley	R	CO-5	No
Tom Tancredo	R	CO-6	No
Bob Beauprez	R	CO-7	No
John Larson	D	CT-1	Aye
Rob Simmons	R	CT-2	No
Rosa DeLauro	D	CT-3	Aye
Christopher Shays	R	CT-4	No
Nancy Johnson	R	CT-5	No
Michael Castle	R	DE-AL	Aye
Jeff Miller	R	FL-1	No
C. Young	R	FL-10	No
Jim Davis	D	FL-11	Aye
Adam Putnam	R	FL-12	No
Katherine Harris	R	FL-13	No
Dave Weldon	R	FL-15	No
Mark Foley	R	FL-16	No
Kendrick Meek	D	FL-17	Not Voting
Ileana Ros-Lehtinen	R	FL-18	No
Robert Wexler	D	FL-19	Aye
Allen Boyd	D	FL-2	Aye
Peter Deutsch	D	FL-20	Aye
Lincoln Diaz-Balart	R	FL-21	No
E. Shaw	R	FL-22	No
Alcee Hastings	D	FL-23	Aye
Tom Feeney	R	FL-24	No
Mario Diaz-Balart	R	FL-25	No
Corrine Brown	D	FL-3	Aye
Ander Crenshaw	R	FL-4	No
Ginny Brown-Waite	R	FL-5	No
Cliff Stearns	R	FL-6	No
John Mica	R	FL-7	No
Ric Keller	R	FL-8	No
Michael Bilirakis	R	FL-9	No
Jack Kingston	R	GA-1	No
Nathan Deal	R	GA-10	No
Phil Gingrey	R	GA-11	No
Max Burns	R	GA-12	No
David Scott	D	GA-13	Aye
Sanford Bishop	D	GA-2	Aye
Jim Marshall	D	GA-3	No
Denise Majette	D	GA-4	Not Voting
John Lewis	D	GA-5	Aye
Johnny Isakson	R	GA-6	No
John Linder	R	GA-7	No
Mac Collins	R	GA-8	No
Charlie Norwood	R	GA-9	Not Voting
Neil Abercrombie	D	HI-1	Aye
Ed Case	D	HI-2	Aye
Jim Nussle	R	IA-1	No
Jim Leach	R	IA-2	Aye
Leonard Boswell	D	IA-3	Aye
Tom Latham	R	IA-4	No
Steve King	R	IA-5	No
Butch Otter	R	ID-1	No
Mike Simpson	R	ID-2	No
Bobby Rush	D	IL-1	Aye
Mark Kirk	R	IL-10	No
Jerry Weller	R	IL-11	No
Jerry Costello	D	IL-12	Aye
Judy Biggert	R	IL-13	No
Denny Hastert	R	IL-14	No
Timothy Johnson	R	IL-15	No
Donald Manzullo	R	IL-16	No
Lane Evans	D	IL-17	Aye
Ray LaHood	R	IL-18	No
John Shimkus	R	IL-19	No
Jesse Jackson	D	IL-2	Aye
William Lipinski	D	IL-3	Not Voting
Luis Gutiérrez	D	IL-4	Aye
Rahm Emanuel	D	IL-5	Aye
Henry Hyde	R	IL-6	No
Danny Davis	D	IL-7	Aye
Phil Crane	R	IL-8	No
Jan Schakowsky	D	IL-9	Aye
Peter Visclosky	D	IN-1	Aye
Chris Chocola	R	IN-2	No
Mark Souder	R	IN-3	No
Steve Buyer	R	IN-4	No
Dan Burton	R	IN-5	No
Mike Pence	R	IN-6	No
Julia Carson	D	IN-7	Aye
John Hostettler	R	IN-8	No
Baron Hill	D	IN-9	Aye
Jerry Moran	R	KS-1	No
Jim Ryun	R	KS-2	No
Dennis Moore	D	KS-3	Aye
Todd Tiahrt	R	KS-4	No
Ed Whitfield	R	KY-1	No
Ron Lewis	R	KY-2	No
Anne Northup	R	KY-3	No
Ken Lucas	D	KY-4	Aye
Hal Rogers	R	KY-5	No
Ben Chandler	D	KY-6	Aye
David Vitter	R	LA-1	No
William Jefferson	D	LA-2	Aye
Billy Tauzin	R	LA-3	Not Voting
Jim McCrery	R	LA-4	No
Rodney Alexander	R	LA-5	No
Richard Baker	R	LA-6	No
Chris John	D	LA-7	Aye
John Olver	D	MA-1	Aye
Bill Delahunt	D	MA-10	Aye
Richard Neal	D	MA-2	Aye
Jim McGovern	D	MA-3	Aye
Barney Frank	D	MA-4	Aye
Marty Meehan	D	MA-5	Aye
John Tierney	D	MA-6	Aye
Ed Markey	D	MA-7	Aye
Michael Capuano	D	MA-8	Aye
Stephen Lynch	D	MA-9	Aye
Wayne Gilchrest	R	MD-1	No
C. Ruppersberger	D	MD-2	Aye
Benjamin Cardin	D	MD-3	Aye
Albert Wynn	D	MD-4	Aye
Steny Hoyer	D	MD-5	Aye
Roscoe Bartlett	R	MD-6	No
Elijah Cummings	D	MD-7	Aye
Chris Van Hollen	D	MD-8	Aye
Tom Allen	D	ME-1	Aye
Michael Michaud	D	ME-2	Aye
Bart Stupak	D	MI-1	Aye
Candice Miller	R	MI-10	No
Thad McCotter	R	MI-11	No
Sander Levin	D	MI-12	Aye
Carolyn Kilpatrick	D	MI-13	Aye
John Conyers	D	MI-14	Aye
John Dingell	D	MI-15	Aye
Pete Hoekstra	R	MI-2	No
Vernon Ehlers	R	MI-3	No
Dave Camp	R	MI-4	No
Dale Kildee	D	MI-5	Aye
Fred Upton	R	MI-6	No
Nick Smith	R	MI-7	No
Mike Rogers	R	MI-8	No
Joe Knollenberg	R	MI-9	No
Gil Gutknecht	R	MN-1	No
John Kline	R	MN-2	No
Jim Ramstad	R	MN-3	No
Betty McCollum	D	MN-4	Aye
Martin Sabo	D	MN-5	No
Mark Kennedy	R	MN-6	No
Collin Peterson	D	MN-7	Aye
James Oberstar	D	MN-8	Aye
Wm. Clay	D	MO-1	Aye
W. Akin	R	MO-2	No
Dick Gephardt	D	MO-3	Not Voting
Ike Skelton	D	MO-4	Aye
Karen McCarthy	D	MO-5	Aye
Sam Graves	R	MO-6	No
Roy Blunt	R	MO-7	No
Jo Ann Emerson	R	MO-8	No
Kenny Hulshof	R	MO-9	No
Roger Wicker	R	MS-1	No
Bennie Thompson	D	MS-2	Aye
Chip Pickering	R	MS-3	No
Gene Taylor	D	MS-4	Aye
Denny Rehberg	R	MT-AL	No
G.K. Butterfield	D	NC-1	Aye
Cass Ballenger	R	NC-10	Not Voting
Charles Taylor	R	NC-11	No
Mel Watt	D	NC-12	Aye
Brad Miller	D	NC-13	Aye
Bob Etheridge	D	NC-2	Aye
Walter Jones	R	NC-3	Not Voting
David Price	D	NC-4	Aye
Richard Burr	R	NC-5	No
Howard Coble	R	NC-6	No
Mike McIntyre	D	NC-7	Aye
Robin Hayes	R	NC-8	No
Sue Myrick	R	NC-9	No
Earl Pomeroy	D	ND-AL	Aye
Lee Terry	R	NE-2	No
Tom Osborne	R	NE-3	No
Jeb Bradley	R	NH-1	No
Charlie Bass	R	NH-2	No
Rob Andrews	D	NJ-1	Aye
Donald Payne	D	NJ-10	Aye
Rodney Frelinghuysen	R	NJ-11	No
Rush Holt	D	NJ-12	Aye
Bob Menendez	D	NJ-13	Aye
Frank LoBiondo	R	NJ-2	No
Jim Saxton	R	NJ-3	No
Chris Smith	R	NJ-4	No
Scott Garrett	R	NJ-5	No
Frank Pallone	D	NJ-6	Aye
Mike Ferguson	R	NJ-7	No
Bill Pascrell	D	NJ-8	Aye
Steven Rothman	D	NJ-9	Aye
Heather Wilson	R	NM-1	No
Steve Pearce	R	NM-2	No
Tom Udall	D	NM-3	Aye
Shelley Berkley	D	NV-1	Aye
Jim Gibbons	R	NV-2	No
Jon Porter	R	NV-3	No
Timothy Bishop	D	NY-1	Aye
Ed Towns	D	NY-10	Not Voting
Major Owens	D	NY-11	Aye
Nydia Velázquez	D	NY-12	Aye
Vito Fossella	R	NY-13	No
Carolyn Maloney	D	NY-14	Aye
Charlie Rangel	D	NY-15	Aye
José Serrano	D	NY-16	Aye
Eliot Engel	D	NY-17	Aye
Nita Lowey	D	NY-18	Aye
Sue Kelly	R	NY-19	No
Steve Israel	D	NY-2	Aye
John Sweeney	R	NY-20	No
Michael McNulty	D	NY-21	Aye
Maurice Hinchey	D	NY-22	Aye
John McHugh	R	NY-23	No
Sherry Boehlert	R	NY-24	Not Voting
Jim Walsh	R	NY-25	No
Thomas Reynolds	R	NY-26	No
Jack Quinn	R	NY-27	No
Louise Slaughter	D	NY-28	Not Voting
Amo Houghton	R	NY-29	No
Pete King	R	NY-3	No
Carolyn McCarthy	D	NY-4	Aye
Gary Ackerman	D	NY-5	Aye
Gregory Meeks	D	NY-6	Aye
Joe Crowley	D	NY-7	Aye
Jerrold Nadler	D	NY-8	Aye
Anthony Weiner	D	NY-9	Aye
Steve Chabot	R	OH-1	No
Dennis Kucinich	D	OH-10	Aye
Stephanie Jones	D	OH-11	Aye
Pat Tiberi	R	OH-12	No
Sherrod Brown	D	OH-13	Aye
Steven LaTourette	R	OH-14	No
Deborah Pryce	R	OH-15	No
Ralph Regula	R	OH-16	No
Tim Ryan	D	OH-17	Aye
Bob Ney	R	OH-18	No
Rob Portman	R	OH-2	No
Michael Turner	R	OH-3	No
Michael Oxley	R	OH-4	No
Paul Gillmor	R	OH-5	No
Ted Strickland	D	OH-6	Aye
Dave Hobson	R	OH-7	No
John Boehner	R	OH-8	No
Marcy Kaptur	D	OH-9	Not Voting
John Sullivan	R	OK-1	No
Brad Carson	D	OK-2	Aye
Frank Lucas	R	OK-3	No
Tom Cole	R	OK-4	No
Ernest Istook	R	OK-5	No
David Wu	D	OR-1	Aye
Greg Walden	R	OR-2	No
Earl Blumenauer	D	OR-3	Aye
Peter DeFazio	D	OR-4	Aye
Darlene Hooley	D	OR-5	Aye
Robert Brady	D	PA-1	Aye
Don Sherwood	R	PA-10	No
Paul Kanjorski	D	PA-11	Aye
John Murtha	D	PA-12	No
Joseph Hoeffel	D	PA-13	Aye
Michael Doyle	D	PA-14	Aye
Pat Toomey	R	PA-15	No
Joseph Pitts	R	PA-16	No
Tim Holden	D	PA-17	Aye
Tim Murphy	R	PA-18	No
Todd Platts	R	PA-19	No
Chaka Fattah	D	PA-2	Aye
Phil English	R	PA-3	No
Melissa Hart	R	PA-4	No
John Peterson	R	PA-5	No
Jim Gerlach	R	PA-6	No
Curt Weldon	R	PA-7	No
Jim Greenwood	R	PA-8	No
Bill Shuster	R	PA-9	No
Patrick Kennedy	D	RI-1	Aye
Jim Langevin	D	RI-2	Aye
Henry Brown	R	SC-1	No
Joe Wilson	R	SC-2	No
J. Gresham Barrett	R	SC-3	No
Jim DeMint	R	SC-4	No
John Spratt	D	SC-5	Aye
Jim Clyburn	D	SC-6	Aye
Stephanie Herseth Sandlin	D	SD-AL	Aye
Bill Jenkins	R	TN-1	No
Jimmy Duncan	R	TN-2	No
Zach Wamp	R	TN-3	No
Lincoln Davis	D	TN-4	Aye
Jim Cooper	D	TN-5	Aye
Bart Gordon	D	TN-6	Aye
Marsha Blackburn	R	TN-7	No
John Tanner	D	TN-8	Aye
Harold Ford	D	TN-9	Aye
Max Sandlin	D	TX-1	Aye
Lloyd Doggett	D	TX-10	Aye
Chet Edwards	D	TX-11	Aye
Kay Granger	R	TX-12	No
Mac Thornberry	R	TX-13	No
Ron Paul	R	TX-14	Not Voting
Rubén Hinojosa	D	TX-15	Not Voting
Silvestre Reyes	D	TX-16	Aye
Charlie Stenholm	D	TX-17	Aye
Sheila Jackson Lee	D	TX-18	Aye
Randy Neugebauer	R	TX-19	No
Jim Turner	D	TX-2	Aye
Charlie Gonzalez	D	TX-20	Aye
Lamar Smith	R	TX-21	No
Tom DeLay	R	TX-22	No
Henry Bonilla	R	TX-23	No
Martin Frost	D	TX-24	Aye
Chris Bell	D	TX-25	Aye
Michael Burgess	R	TX-26	No
Solomon Ortiz	D	TX-27	Not Voting
Ciro Rodriguez	D	TX-28	Aye
Gene Green	D	TX-29	Aye
Sam Johnson	R	TX-3	No
Eddie Johnson	D	TX-30	Aye
John Carter	R	TX-31	No
Pete Sessions	R	TX-32	No
Ralph Hall	R	TX-4	No
Jeb Hensarling	R	TX-5	No
Joe Barton	R	TX-6	No
John Culberson	R	TX-7	No
Kevin Brady	R	TX-8	No
Nick Lampson	D	TX-9	Aye
Rob Bishop	R	UT-1	No
Jim Matheson	D	UT-2	Aye
Chris Cannon	R	UT-3	No
Jo Ann Davis	R	VA-1	No
Frank Wolf	R	VA-10	No
Tom Davis	R	VA-11	No
Ed Schrock	R	VA-2	No
Bobby Scott	D	VA-3	Aye
J. Forbes	R	VA-4	No
Virgil Goode	R	VA-5	No
Bob Goodlatte	R	VA-6	No
Eric Cantor	R	VA-7	No
Jim Moran	D	VA-8	Aye
Rick Boucher	D	VA-9	Aye
Bernie Sanders	I	VT-AL	Aye
Jay Inslee	D	WA-1	Aye
Rick Larsen	D	WA-2	Aye
Brian Baird	D	WA-3	Aye
Doc Hastings	R	WA-4	No
George Nethercutt	R	WA-5	No
Norm Dicks	D	WA-6	Aye
Jim McDermott	D	WA-7	Aye
Jennifer Dunn	R	WA-8	No
Adam Smith	D	WA-9	Aye
Paul Ryan	R	WI-1	No
Tammy Baldwin	D	WI-2	Aye
Ron Kind	D	WI-3	Aye
Jerry Kleczka	D	WI-4	Aye
F. Sensenbrenner	R	WI-5	No
Tom Petri	R	WI-6	No
Dave Obey	D	WI-7	No
Mark Green	R	WI-8	No
Alan Mollohan	D	WV-1	Aye
Shelley Capito	R	WV-2	No
Nick Rahall	D	WV-3	Aye
Barbara Cubin	R	WY-AL	No