VotedBy VotedBy ⌕
Election Day · Tue, Nov 3See how your members of Congress voted →

S.J.Res. 50 · 116th Congress

A joint resolution providing for congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of…

Full title

A joint resolution providing for congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of the rule submitted by the Internal Revenue Service, Department of the Treasury, relating to "Contributions in Exchange for State or Local Tax Credits".

Key: what the circles and colors mean

Each circle is a bill. The ring fills as it moves through Congress:

IntroducedPassed one chamberPassed both chambersBecame law (gold)Resolution agreed to (full, dark)Failed or vetoed (gray)

Under the number: the Yea · Nay count of its final (or latest) recorded vote. On a member's page, the small badge is how that member voted: Y Yea / Aye, N Nay / No, P Present, – Not voting.

Gold and violet are only for Yea and Nay; they never mean a party. A member's party is the letter on their photo.

CSD SchumerSponsor
12 cosponsors · 12 D
  1. Senate Introduced Jul 16, 2019
  2. Senate Failed Oct 23, 2019 43–52

This resolution expresses congressional disapproval of the rule submitted by the Internal Revenue Service relating to charitable contribution and estate tax deductions when a taxpayer receives or expects to receive a corresponding state or local tax credit, and such rule shall have no force or effect.

What it does: CRS summary · Introduced in Senate · Jul 16, 2019

This resolution expresses congressional disapproval of the rule submitted by the Internal Revenue Service relating to charitable contribution and estate tax deductions when a taxpayer receives or expects to receive a corresponding state or local tax credit, and such rule shall have no force or effect.

Written by the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service. All summary versions on Congress.gov

Votes to become law

Senate · Joint Resolution Defeated Oct 23, 2019 · 43 Yea – 52 Nay Passage Majority Leader: Mitch McConnell
About this bill and sources

Official title: A joint resolution providing for congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of the rule submitted by the Internal Revenue Service, Department of the Treasury, relating to "Contributions in Exchange for State or Local Tax Credits".

Latest action (Oct 23, 2019): Failed of passage in Senate by Yea-Nay Vote. 43 - 52. Record Vote Number: 331.

Policy area: Taxation · Origin: Senate · Introduced: Jul 16, 2019

Official page on Congress.gov · Bill text (GovInfo) · Status record (XML) · Embed in your story

  1. Senate Introduced Jul 16, 2019
  2. Senate Failed Oct 23, 2019 43–52

Final vote · Senate · Oct 23, 2019

Passage — Joint Resolution Defeated. Vote details

Senate Majority Leader: Mitch McConnell

Yea43
DJD Jones KSD Sinema DFD Feinstein CMD Murphy RBD Blumenthal CCD Coons TCD Carper BSD Schatz MHD Hirono RDD Durbin TDD Duckworth RPR Paul EMD Markey BCD Cardin CVD Van Hollen AKI King DSD Stabenow GPD Peters AKD Klobuchar TSD Smith JTD Tester JSD Shaheen MHD Hassan BMD Menendez CBD Booker MHD Heinrich TUD Udall CCD Cortez Masto JRD Rosen CSD Schumer KGD Gillibrand SBD Brown JMD Merkley RWD Wyden BCD Casey JRD Reed MWD Warner TKD Kaine PLD Leahy MCD Cantwell PMD Murray TBD Baldwin JMD Manchin
Nay52
DSR Sullivan LMR Murkowski RSR Shelby JBR Boozman TCR Cotton MMR McSally CGR Gardner MBD Bennet MRR Rubio RSR Scott DPR Perdue CGR Grassley JER Ernst JRR Risch MCR Crapo MBR Braun TYR Young JMR Moran PRR Roberts MMR McConnell BCR Cassidy JKR Kennedy SCR Collins JHR Hawley RBR Blunt CHR Hyde-Smith RWR Wicker SDR Daines RBR Burr TTR Tillis JHR Hoeven KCR Cramer BSR Sasse DFR Fischer RPR Portman JLR Lankford JIR Inhofe PTR Toomey LGR Graham TSR Scott JTR Thune MRR Rounds LAR Alexander MBR Blackburn JCR Cornyn TCR Cruz MLR Lee MRR Romney RJR Johnson SCR Capito JBR Barrasso MER Enzi
Not Voting5
KHD Harris JIR Isakson EWD Warren SWD Whitehouse BSI Sanders
Table of every position
MemberParty at voteSeatPosition
Dan SullivanRAKNay
Lisa MurkowskiRAKNay
Doug JonesDALYea
Richard ShelbyRALNay
John BoozmanRARNay
Tom CottonRARNay
Kyrsten SinemaDAZYea
Martha McSallyRAZNay
Dianne FeinsteinDCAYea
Kamala HarrisDCANot Voting
Cory GardnerRCONay
Michael BennetDCONay
Christopher MurphyDCTYea
Richard BlumenthalDCTYea
Christopher CoonsDDEYea
Thomas CarperDDEYea
Marco RubioRFLNay
Rick ScottRFLNay
David PerdueRGANay
Johnny IsaksonRGANot Voting
Brian SchatzDHIYea
Mazie HironoDHIYea
Chuck GrassleyRIANay
Joni ErnstRIANay
James RischRIDNay
Mike CrapoRIDNay
Richard DurbinDILYea
Tammy DuckworthDILYea
Mike BraunRINNay
Todd YoungRINNay
Jerry MoranRKSNay
Pat RobertsRKSNay
Mitch McConnellRKYNay
Rand PaulRKYYea
Bill CassidyRLANay
John KennedyRLANay
Ed MarkeyDMAYea
Elizabeth WarrenDMANot Voting
Benjamin CardinDMDYea
Chris Van HollenDMDYea
Angus KingIMEYea
Susan CollinsRMENay
Debbie StabenowDMIYea
Gary PetersDMIYea
Amy KlobucharDMNYea
Tina SmithDMNYea
Josh HawleyRMONay
Roy BluntRMONay
Cindy Hyde-SmithRMSNay
Roger WickerRMSNay
Jon TesterDMTYea
Steve DainesRMTNay
Richard BurrRNCNay
Thom TillisRNCNay
John HoevenRNDNay
Kevin CramerRNDNay
Ben SasseRNENay
Deb FischerRNENay
Jeanne ShaheenDNHYea
Maggie HassanDNHYea
Bob MenendezDNJYea
Cory BookerDNJYea
Martin HeinrichDNMYea
Tom UdallDNMYea
Catherine Cortez MastoDNVYea
Jacky RosenDNVYea
Chuck SchumerDNYYea
Kirsten GillibrandDNYYea
Rob PortmanROHNay
Sherrod BrownDOHYea
James LankfordROKNay
Jim InhofeROKNay
Jeff MerkleyDORYea
Ron WydenDORYea
Bob CaseyDPAYea
Pat ToomeyRPANay
Jack ReedDRIYea
Sheldon WhitehouseDRINot Voting
Lindsey GrahamRSCNay
Tim ScottRSCNay
John ThuneRSDNay
Mike RoundsRSDNay
Lamar AlexanderRTNNay
Marsha BlackburnRTNNay
John CornynRTXNay
Ted CruzRTXNay
Mike LeeRUTNay
Mitt RomneyRUTNay
Mark WarnerDVAYea
Tim KaineDVAYea
Bernie SandersIVTNot Voting
Patrick LeahyDVTYea
Maria CantwellDWAYea
Patty MurrayDWAYea
Ron JohnsonRWINay
Tammy BaldwinDWIYea
Joe ManchinDWVYea
Shelley CapitoRWVNay
John BarrassoRWYNay
Michael EnziRWYNay